× You are not currently logged in. To receive all the benefits our site has to offer, we encourage you to log in now.

2022 Evidence-Based Design Touchstone Award Recipients


View the 2022 Touchstone Award recipient award ceremony video here.

PLATINUM category


 

 
ProMedica Generations of Care Tower, HKS

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that this is a solid example of how to take on a larger EBD project, maintain identified goals, plan, execute and evaluate. The evaluation was strong, included appropriate research questions, relational hypotheses and objective metrics with a clear link between research, design decisions and staff engagement. 

The ProMedica Generations of Care Tower promotes a well-connected environment with a strong link to community through transparency in design and process. The design combines applied research, smart technology, evidence-based design, and sustainability to create a modern patient tower that exemplifies comfort and transformative care inside and out. User-friendly technology infused throughout the facility encourages multi-disciplinary collaboration and coordination between staff and patients to improve clinical outcomes. Research integration (including parametric tools) has contributed to increasing patient satisfaction, care givers access and time with patients, as well as reducing wasted walking by caregivers in half.

 

 
North Torrey Pines Living and Learning Neighborhood, HKS, UC San Diego & CADRE

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that this was a carefully constructed project, extraordinarily grounded in EBD, research, and analysis that linked design strategies to create environments that promote positive behaviors, contribute to desired outcomes and future capital planning. 

The New Sixth College is a living lab that uses architecture to augment positive behaviors and outcomes and integrates that understanding into current academics and future capital planning. North Torrey Pines Living and Learning Neighborhood is a new residential “campus within a campus” at UC San Diego providing an affordable on-campus living experience with a focus on physical and mental well-being, a connection to community and a commitment to the environment.

  

 
 
 

 

Stamford Hospital, EYP, now Page

Read about the project >

Jurors thought that overall, thoughtful consideration was given to the project's vision, Planetree principles and user engagement. 

Meeting the needs of the community and never losing sight of the goals to personalize, humanize, and demystify healthcare, an empathetic approach and collaboration between clinicians, administrators, and architects drove the design of this Planetree Designated® Patient-Centered hospital. The result of a comprehensive long-range master plan, the new 650,000 sq. ft Hospital’s design embraces every opportunity to demonstrate person-centered care. The 12-floor, 180 private-patient room hospital focuses on empowerment, dignity and compassion with an underlying foundation in safety, effectiveness, and comfort for patients and caregivers.

 

Froedtert & the Medical College of Wisconsin; 7 North Tower Build-out Unit, HGA

Read about the project >

Jurors found the completion of a long term, multi- phased POE study to gauge continuous improvement was exemplary and illustrated the ongoing buy-in and commitment from the health system. 

For this project, a series of Lean exercises and research tools were deployed to create a Lean + evidence-based unit design. Lean exercises such as critical-to-quality prioritization, peer-to-peer interviewing, and space adjacency diagramming were held with user groups. In addition, predesign research including staff shadowing, and staff and patient interviews were completed. Resulting baseline data led to the development of critical-to-quality metrics that were used to guide planning and design decisions. Common travel paths uncovered during shadowing were diagrammed in three proposed unit prototypes to compare travel distances. These activities were paramount in receiving buy-in from stakeholders for room count and size decisions.

 

 

Great Plains Health, HDR, Inc.

Read about the project >

Jurors were impressed with the consistent use of the EBD process throughout the project, the commitment from leadership, and the benefits of using research to drive the design of their new facility. Inclusion of patient and family representatives from the inception was key and showed in the outcomes and impact. 

Great Plains Health serves both inpatients and outpatients of all age groups, with varying disease conditions at all levels of acuity. It serves a 17-county region including Nebraska, northern Kansas and southern South Dakota. The staff population includes those who work at the facility and are responsible for patient care, administration, and maintenance.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

Eating Recovery Center Willow, Boulder Associates

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that the evaluation was well informed by existing literature, and made strong connections between literature and design decisions. The research questions were distilled into measurable outcomes and were re-evaluated during the POE. 

Eating Recovery Center’s mission is to take the very best care of patients, families, providers, and teammates as they deliver the highest quality treatment for patients with eating disorders. Eating Recovery Center Willow is a tenant improvement for a 72-bed, 58,970 s.f. licensed psychiatric hospital treating eating disorders serving adults and children & adolescents in Denver, Colorado. To inform the design of Willow, the team conducted a pre-design analysis of three existing ERC facilities, and a post-occupancy evaluation of six ERC facilities, including Willow. This was the largest portfolio-wide research study conducted by Boulder Associates to date.

 

 

 

GOLD Category


 
UPMC Presbyterian Bed Tower, HGA

Read about the project >

Jurors thought the applicant was thorough, thoughtful, detailed and consistent in their approach, integrating EBD at every step. The business case showed the potential for operational savings that would come from nursing staff efficiency and more time spent at the bedside. 

Pittsburgh’s evolution as a global center of medical science takes a dramatic step forward with UPMC’s investment in visionary approaches to healthcare. One aspect of that future arrives in 2022, with the opening of the UPMC Heart and Transplant Hospital at UPMC Presbyterian. The hospital’s bold architecture will communicate UPMC’s capabilities as a world-class healthcare provider. UPMC and HGA’s transformative approach to hospital-based care includes using digital technology to simplify treatment and enhance person-to-person connections; providing natural spaces in concert with beautiful architecture to boost the healing power of a serene environment; and creating radically clear patient pathways and planning enhanced by nature and dramatic design.

 

 

 

Toward A Model Of Safety And Care For Trauma Room Design, Master Of Healthcare Design Program, Kent State University, Cleveland Clinic Akron General

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that this is an excellent academic research project that operationalizes an EBD process for a conceptual design exploration that uses mockups and simulation techniques. Lessons can be learned from this model for practice. 

"Toward a Model of Safety and Care for Trauma Room Design" is a project funded by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ). It is a cross-disciplinary collaboration between Kent State University and Cleveland Clinic Akron General. The project aims to help save patients’ lives by improving the design of Level I trauma rooms. Goals of the project include developing design strategies to integrate technology and maximize future adaptability, testing proposed design strategies for a trauma room, and developing an evidence-based model for designing trauma rooms that support efficient and safe patient care.

 

 

 

Reimagining the Behavioral Health Experience, Philips

Read about the project >

By using an existing product for a new purpose, jurors found this to be a strong project. They particularly appreciated the commitment to continually adapt the project/product based on data as it is received. The project has gathered qualitative data with plans for a more rigorous evaluation. 

The Behavioral Health Experience solution is an adaptive environment for pediatric behavioral health patients in the Emergency Department (ED) that seeks to support de-escalation, expedite therapy, and create new connections with staff. Many adolescents seeking mental health care end up in their local ED as a last resort and experience psychiatric boarding – held for days or even weeks in a secure but empty room. By integrating a specialized touchscreen with ambient room technology and therapeutic content, exam rooms are transformed into ultra-tunable environments to help improve care delivery and support improved ED throughput.

 

 

 

Corner Brook Acute Care Hospital - Wayfinding Research Project, Parkin Architects with Dr. Saleh Kalantari, Cornell University

Read about the project >

Jurors found this to be an interesting study and appreciated the understanding of the impact and potential of this novel process as a viable and valuable addition to design. 

The research project culminating in a recently published article in the Journal of Environmental Psychology follows parallel themes; 1 – a robust evaluation of augmented design to support intuitive signage and wayfinding systems in an acute care hospital using virtual immersion (VR) and biometric data to provide rigorous human response testing prior to construction; 2 – the validity of virtual immersion (VR) and biometric data as a tool to evaluate human response to environmental stimulus during the design stage of a project, including an understanding of logistics and return on investment.

 

ATLAS Virtual Care Station, Philips & Steelcase Health

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that there is a crisp and clear vision and objectives. They believe that this is a valuable project that could provide better access to quality healthcare. 

The US Department of Veterans Affairs provides healthcare to nearly 9 million veterans, one-third of whom live in rural areas. Providing care to rural veterans presents real delivery challenges. Geographic and digital divides can make it hard for veterans to get the care they need. To solve this challenge Steelcase Health and Philips Healthcare came together to create Virtual Care Stations that brings care to veterans where and when they need it most. This allows veterans to be examined at their local post through virtual appointments with medical professionals across the country, saving veterans long highway hours and travel expenses.

 
 

 

SILVER Category


 
Hirair and Anna Hovnanian Emergency Care Center, Ocean Medical Center, EYP, now Page

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that there was great integration between the clinical staff and the design team, with a variety of interdisciplinary experts and stakeholders participating in multiple phases. 

The new Hirair and Anna Hovnanian Emergency Care Center, is a transformational project where the hospital was challenged with a rising emergency patient census, including meeting the needs of multiple, vulnerable, patient populations. The multidisciplinary team worked closely to understand patients’ needs and to remove barriers for prompt access to Emergency care. The hospital considered specific populations, such as meeting the needs of ethnic groups, offering all private rooms, and comfortable amenities for family. The new Emergency Department doubled capacity, using patient and staff-centered design, Lean processes, and new technologies. The Emergency Department also includes a Behavioral Health Unit.

 

 

UW Health Eastpark Medical Center, HKS

Read about the project >

Jurors found that the articulation of the research and evaluation plan was particularly strong with education-rich deliverables, and should be shared to enrich the evidence-base for all oncology and outpatient projects. 

Eastpark Medical Center will serve as the eastern gateway to UW Health’s distinctive programs and an outpatient prototype for two more locations that will enable better access, improve patient and staff experiences, facilitate coordinated care and expand the use of digital health. Located on a 27-acre site, the design centers around the idea that modern healthcare should not only treat the illness but drive a paradigm shift to promote health and vitality of community, creating sustainable wellness. The 461,000 sf facility features seven stories and anchor clinical programs for Oncology and Advanced Women’s services. The project will open September 2024.

 

 

Scripps Design Collaborative, HGA

Read about the project >

Jurors found the research plan methodical and clearly constructed. This project was unique with a model unit and multiple buildings, and demonstrated the value and positive impact of an EBD process across a health system. 

Scripps treats more than 700,000 patients annually through the dedication of 3,000 affiliated physicians and more than 15,000 employees among its five acute-care hospital campuses, home health care services, and an ambulatory care network of physician offices and 28 outpatient centers and clinics.

 

 
 

 

 

Utah Valley Hospital, HDR, Inc.

Read about the project >

Jurors liked that in preparation the team conducted site visits, a pre-planning analysis, explored the impacts on patients, staff, and visitors and intentionally engaged community stakeholders as the facility is an integral part of the community. 

Utah Valley Hospital is a Level II Trauma Center located in Provo, Utah County, Utah. The hospital serves as a referral center for central and southern Utah. The hospital has 359 staffed beds and offers a broad spectrum of inpatient and outpatient services. Key programs at the facility include the Utah Valley Hospital Primary Children’s Network, the Utah Valley Heart Center, NICU, and Cancer Services.

 

 
 

 

Alden Courts of Shorewood, ADG Design

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that the EBD goals were clear and laudable.This is an important building type that would benefit from sharing with other owners and design professionals. 

Alden Courts of Shorewood is short-term rehabilitation and skilled nursing facility specializing in memory care. The design of the building is conducive to enriching the lives of the residents and enabling the staff to offer better quality of care and support. The project team used EBD practices to change what typical memory care design has been and created innovative designs for the owner, that has now become the standard for all future memory care projects.

 

 

 

Sheltering Arms Institute, HDR, Inc.

Read about the project >

Jurors liked that there was good user engagement with over 200+ stakeholders, patients, and families over 15 months to educate them about EBD, visioning and design planning. 

The new Sheltering Arms Institute (SAI) sits on a 25-acre campus development on the west side of Richmond, Virginia. The Institute was planned and designed to operate according to the VCU Health Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) model and future spinal cord model systems of care and is one of eight facilities in the US with this designation. The planning and design philosophy revolved around the idea of the building as a therapeutic tool. The design integrates research with clinical care, incorporates rehabilitative innovations and technologies to impact clinical practice, and intends to improve the quality of the patient and family therapeutic experience, reinventing rehabilitation for “life beyond limits.”

 

 

Providence Care Hospital, Methologica & Parkin Architects

Read about the project >

Jurors found it interesting that the project used a P3 approach and engaged a collaborative team to apply the EBD process. There was a clear link between the design decisions and hypothesized outcomes. 

Providence Care Hospital is unique as Canada’s first fully integrated rehabilitation facility, treating physical and mental health, focused on creating equitable access to resources, promoting recovery and transition; fostering connection and connectivity with people and their surroundings; creating a healing environment; enhancing the staff; patient experience; enhancing comingling (of all users); and reducing stigma. The Alternative Finance and Procurement project delivery model lead to an adapted EBD process to fulfill the Hospitals vision, which was defined by Providence Care Hospital and HOK, integrated into the design by Parkin Architects and evaluated in POE by Methologica.

 

 

Henry Ford Macomb Hospital North Patient Tower, AECOM with Enviah

Read about the project >

Jurors stated that the visioning, brainstorming and stakeholder engagement was well done and that the project outcome embodies the EBD process. 

Healthcare is changing rapidly and the need to adapt and support change requires a highly integrated and flexible planning model. Projected population growth and increasing need for tertiary inpatient care, guided the solution for a future ready patient tower. The design integrates the physical environment and advanced technology to achieve leading clinical outcomes, embrace the patient and support the staff to work at the top of their license. AECOM and Enviah used an evidence based design led four-dimensional process – Define, Discover, Design and Do, to create a facility centered on providing patient care with compassion, innovation, respect, and results.